When choosing a paint color, it’s tempting to go with whatever is trending right now. The problem is, many of today’s “must-have” shades will look tired and outdated in just a few years. At Brightline Painting, we’ve helped countless homeowners update colors they once loved but now can’t wait to cover.
This guide highlights five paint colors experts agree you’ll likely regret in 10 years, along with timeless alternatives that will keep your home looking fresh for decades.
Bright red walls can make a bold statement, but in a decade, that boldness often turns into visual fatigue. High-gloss reds also tend to show every imperfection on your walls.
Timeless alternative: Try Benjamin Moore Caliente AF-290 in a satin finish for a softer, more versatile take, or opt for Sherwin-Williams Heartthrob SW 6866 as an accent rather than a whole room.
Neon green or electric blue might feel fun in the moment, but their appeal fades quickly. They’re also difficult to match with furnishings and fixtures over time.
Timeless alternative: Consider muted, nature-inspired versions like Sherwin-Williams Sea Salt SW 6204 or Benjamin Moore Palladian Blue HC-144, which offer color without overwhelming the space.
For years, cool grays were the go-to for modern interiors, but their popularity is waning. In 10 years, an all-gray home could feel cold and dated.
Timeless alternative: Warm neutrals like Sherwin-Williams Accessible Beige SW 7036 or Benjamin Moore Manchester Tan HC-81 bring the same sophistication with added warmth. See more about this trend in our post on Warm Neutrals 2025.
Deep, chocolatey browns can make a room feel heavy and closed in. Over time, they can also make spaces appear smaller.
Timeless alternative: Lighter earth tones like Sherwin-Williams Nomadic Desert SW 6107 keep the warmth without the visual weight, making them ideal for both modern and traditional spaces.
Crisp white can feel fresh, but using it everywhere can lead to a sterile look. Over time, white walls can also yellow or show wear more easily.
Timeless alternative: Soft whites like Benjamin Moore White Dove OC-17 or Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008 offer warmth and flexibility without losing that clean look.
Repainting every few years to stay on trend can add up quickly. Choosing classic, versatile colors now means you’ll love your space longer, and you’ll avoid the expense and disruption of frequent repaints.
If you’re unsure which direction to go, our team can help. We know how colors behave in Greenville, Spartanburg, Simpsonville, and other Upstate South Carolina communities, factoring in lighting, architecture, and your home’s unique style. Learn more about us on Who We Are and Our Journey.
Avoid the regret. Choose colors you’ll love for years with help from Brightline Painting. We’ll guide you to shades that are beautiful today and will stand the test of time.
Get your free color consultation and painting quote today and start your home’s transformation.