Why Some Paint Colors Don’t Stand the Test of Time

When choosing paint colors, it’s easy to be swayed by trends. The problem? Many of today’s “must-have” shades lose their charm quickly, leaving homeowners eager to repaint. At Brightline Painting, we’ve seen it firsthand — colors that felt stylish a few years ago now look dated and dull.

Here are five paint colors experts say you may regret in 10 years, along with timeless alternatives to keep your home looking fresh.

1. High-Gloss Bright Red
Bold at first, but overwhelming long-term. High-gloss finishes also highlight wall imperfections.
👉 Try instead: Benjamin Moore Caliente AF-290 or Sherwin-Williams Heartthrob SW 6866 as an accent.

2. Neon or Ultra-Bright Colors
Fun for a moment, but hard to live with daily and difficult to pair with furniture.
👉 Try instead: Muted tones like Sherwin-Williams Sea Salt SW 6204 or Benjamin Moore Palladian Blue HC-144.

3. Cool Gray Overload
Once a modern staple, but now fading. Entirely gray homes can feel cold.
👉 Try instead: Warm neutrals such as Sherwin-Williams Accessible Beige SW 7036 or Benjamin Moore Manchester Tan HC-81.

4. Heavy Dark Browns
Rich but weighty, making rooms feel smaller over time.
👉 Try instead: Earth tones like Sherwin-Williams Nomadic Desert SW 6107 for warmth without heaviness.

5. Pure White Everywhere
Clean but sterile, with wear and yellowing more noticeable.
👉 Try instead: Softer whites like Benjamin Moore White Dove OC-17 or Sherwin-Williams Alabaster SW 7008.

Why Timeless Colors Matter

Repainting every few years to “stay on trend” adds cost and stress. Choosing classic, versatile shades means your home stays stylish for decades — without frequent makeovers.

Not sure where to begin? Brightline Painting offers free color consultations across Greenville, Spartanburg, Simpsonville, and beyond. We’ll help you pick colors that look great today and in the future.

👉 Call us at (864) 900-9513 to start your transformation today!